Amendments to the ZHD from 1 January 2020: What changed for Croatian expats and their descendants
The amendments to the Zakon o hrvatskom državljanstvu (Official Gazette Nos. 53/91, 70/91, 28/92, 113/93, 4/94, 130/11, 110/15, 102/19, 138/21; hereinafter: ZHD), which entered into force on 1 January 2020, clearly affected the acquisition of citizenship on the basis of emigration and descent from emigrants. The legislator’s main aim was to define the term “emigrant” more precisely and to limit and systematically regulate the criteria for establishing the right of descendants and their spouses to facilitated acquisition of citizenship.
The amendments to Article 11 ZHD clearly focused on the substance of emigration: the statutory definition of an emigrant requires that the person emigrated from the territory of the Republic of Croatia with the intention of residing abroad permanently, and exceptions were also introduced that exclude its application (for example, emigration under an international treaty, renunciation of citizenship, or a change of domicile within the state unions). In doing so, the legislator moved towards a substantive determination of status, meaning that the right of descendants does not depend on the formal administrative classification of family members but on the actual genealogical and migration facts (Croatian Government’s explanatory memorandum to the proposed amendments to the ZHD, 2019).
Who is considered an emigrant under Article 11 ZHD?
In everyday language, Croats who left the country and their families are often called Croatian expats, but the ZHD uses the term emigrant and sets precise conditions for it. Under Article 11(3) ZHD, an emigrant is a person who, before 8 October 1991, emigrated from the territory of the Republic of Croatia with the intention of living abroad permanently. By way of exception, an emigrant is also a member of the Croatian people who emigrated from the territory of former states which, at the time of emigration, also included the territory of today’s Republic of Croatia (Article 11(4) ZHD).
On the other hand, the following persons are not considered emigrants (Article 11(5) ZHD):
- a person who emigrated from the territory of the Republic of Croatia under an international treaty,
- a person who renounced Croatian citizenship,
- a person who moved their domicile to other states that were, at the time, part of the state union to which the Republic of Croatia also belonged,
- a person who emigrated from the territory of the Republic of Croatia but did not hold former Croatian republic citizenship or zavičajnost in the territory of the Republic of Croatia.
The third exception is a common obstacle in practice. In judgment case no. UsI-742/18-12 of 26 February 2019, the Administrative Court in Zagreb concluded that the claimant was not a descendant of an emigrant because his family first moved from Croatia to Slovenia and only then to Italy.
Which requirements do Croatian expats, their descendants and spouses not have to meet?
An emigrant and their descendants may acquire Croatian citizenship by naturalisation even if they do not meet the requirements of Article 8(1)(2) to (4) ZHD (Article 11(1) ZHD). This means that they do not need to be released from their foreign citizenship, do not need to have lived in the Republic of Croatia continuously for eight years with approved permanent residence, and do not take the Croatian language, culture and social system test. The same applies to a foreign national married to an emigrant or their descendant (Article 11(2) ZHD).
All of them must still meet the requirements of Article 8(1)(1) and (5) ZHD. They must therefore be at least 18 years old, respect the legal order of the Republic of Croatia and have paid all public charges due, and there must be no security obstacles to their admission to Croatian citizenship. A minor child acquires Croatian citizenship by naturalisation if one of the parents acquires citizenship under Article 11(1) ZHD (Article 13, point 3 ZHD).
How to prove that an expat ancestor emigrated from Croatia?
When applying Article 11 ZHD, it is crucial to prove that the ancestor emigrated specifically from the territory of the Republic of Croatia and that there was an intention to reside permanently abroad. In practice, this requires original documentation: a domovnica, a deregistration of domicile or a passport with visas or stamps, certificates of registered domicile or residence abroad issued by local authorities, certificates of employment and social insurance in the country to which the ancestor emigrated, pension statements and tax records.
Ship manifests as proof of a Croatian expat ancestor’s emigration
It is also worth mentioning the ship manifest, the official list of passengers on departure or arrival. It can be very valuable evidence of an ancestor’s emigration because it shows the date and route of the journey, the passenger’s name, age, citizenship, place of departure and destination. As a primary source from the time of emigration, a manifest can prove that the ancestor physically left the territory of Croatia (or the former Yugoslavia) and where they permanently headed, which helps prove actual emigration and the chronology of migration. Where the journey began in Croatia or the former Yugoslavia, relevant sources include port archives (for example in Rijeka, Split and elsewhere) and maritime archives, local city archives (registry offices, municipal archives), the Croatian State Archives and its branches, shipping company archives, and databases of commercial services that digitise manifests (for example Ancestry, Findmypast and the Ellis Island database for the USA).
How to prove the family line and where to apply?
In addition to evidence of emigration, the applicant must prove their kinship with the emigrant in every generation, as a rule with birth and marriage certificates for each generation from the emigrant to the applicant. Since a person who did not hold former Croatian republic citizenship or zavičajnost in the territory of the Republic of Croatia is not considered an emigrant, it is useful to obtain evidence of this as well, for example the ancestor’s domovnica or their entry in the citizenship register. As a rule, foreign documents must be translated into Croatian by an authorised court interpreter and, depending on the issuing country, certified with an apostille or legalised.
The application is submitted in person at the police administration or police station according to the place of approved residence, or through a diplomatic mission or consular office of the Republic of Croatia abroad (Article 24 ZHD). For Croatian expats and their descendants living abroad, applying through a diplomatic mission or consulate is usually the most practical option.
Can the Ministry of the Interior refuse an application even if the requirements are met?
Yes. Under Article 26(2) ZHD, the Ministry of the Interior may refuse an application for citizenship even if the requirements are met, if it considers that there are reasons in the interest of the Republic of Croatia for refusing it. The reasons for refusal need not be stated in the decision (Article 26(3) ZHD).
Conclusion: How to prepare the documentation for the application
In light of the above, applicants for Croatian citizenship, including descendants of Croatian expats, should aim to submit documentation of their ancestors’ migration that is as original and chronologically consistent as possible, including official certificates of domicile registration and deregistration, employment and social insurance records, and pension documents. As regards spouses, the family line and the authenticity of the evidence of the ancestors’ emigration should be proven systematically.