Acquiring Croatian citizenship on the basis of membership of the Croatian people is one of the legal grounds for acquiring Croatian citizenship by naturalisation, and it is governed by Article 16 of the Zakon o hrvatskom državljanstvu (Official Gazette Nos. 53/91, 70/91, 28/92, 113/93, 4/94, 130/11, 110/15, 102/19, 138/21; hereinafter: ZHD).
Requirements for Croatian citizenship based on membership of the Croatian people
Under that provision, as amended by the amendments to the ZHD that entered into force on 1 January 2020, a member of the Croatian people who is not domiciled in the Republic of Croatia may acquire Croatian citizenship if they meet the requirements of Article 8(1)(5) ZHD, namely that they respect the legal order of the Republic of Croatia, have paid all public charges due and that there are no security obstacles to their admission to Croatian citizenship. Membership of the Croatian people is established by an earlier declaration of that membership in legal transactions, by its statement in certain public documents, by protecting the rights and promoting the interests of the Croatian people, and by active participation in Croatian cultural, scientific and sports associations abroad.
Zagreb Administrative Court judgment UsI-742/18-12: The facts
Under current case law, specifically the judgment of the Administrative Court in Zagreb, case no. UsI-742/18-12 of 26 February 2019, the claimant M. B., an Italian national, applied for admission to Croatian citizenship on 29 August 2014 as a person relying on membership of the Croatian people and/or as a descendant of an emigrant. It was established that his grandmother A. M. was born in the town of P. in the Republic of Croatia and was of Croatian ethnicity, while the claimant’s mother was born in Slovenia, married an Italian national and later moved to Italy together with her parents.
As evidence of his membership of the Croatian people and his status as a descendant of an emigrant, the applicant submitted a certified statement of his ethnicity, his grandmother’s birth and baptism certificate, her marriage certificate and domovnica, a certificate of his grandmother’s enrolment in the school register, a certificate of membership in the Croatian-Italian Association in the town of R., a certificate of honorary membership in the cultural and arts society “Z.” in P., a statement by the witness M. Ć. that the claimant is ethnically Croatian, photographs of stays in the Republic of Croatia, a photograph of a vehicle with a Croatian national sticker, a membership card of the National and University Library, a copy of his CV, a certificate of no criminal record and other circumstances which, according to the claimant, showed his connection with Croatian culture and identity.
Which evidence of membership of the Croatian people did the court reject?
A statement certified by a notary public that the applicant is Croatian was not accepted as sufficient evidence. The court held that a personal statement alone, without an earlier declaration in legal transactions or an entry in public documents, does not prove lasting and credible membership of the Croatian people within the meaning of Article 16 ZHD.
The certificate of membership in the Croatian-Italian Association was not accepted either. The court took into account that the membership began immediately before or after the application was submitted, so such activity lacks the character of earlier, continuous and credible involvement in Croatian associations abroad that the law requires as proof of membership.
The certificate of honorary and supporting membership in the cultural and arts society “Z.” was not accepted as proof of the applicant’s membership because the work and participation concerned activities in the territory of the Republic of Croatia, while Article 16 ZHD requires active and continuous participation in Croatian cultural associations abroad as a relevant indicator of membership.
The witness statement on the applicant’s membership of the Croatian people was not accepted as independent evidence. The court found that uncertified and vague testimony, with no basis in earlier official documentation or continuous activity, cannot by itself confirm a lasting national affiliation.
Photographs taken during visits to the Republic of Croatia were not accepted because occasional visits to the country do not prove an earlier declaration in legal transactions or lasting membership of the Croatian people; such photographs have limited evidentiary value.
The photograph of a vehicle with a sticker of the Republic of Croatia was not accepted because it is a symbolic act that does not show a lasting national affiliation; the court even pointed out that displaying such a sticker may be unlawful and is therefore irrelevant as proof of membership.
The membership card of the National and University Library in Zagreb was not accepted as proof of membership because merely using the library during a visit is neither an earlier declaration in legal transactions nor a continuous link with Croatian community activities abroad.
The entry “Croatian” in the nationality field of the application form was not accepted as credible proof of genuine affiliation; the court found that such an entry may be motivated by the wish to acquire citizenship more easily and is not an earlier, credible declaration of national affiliation.
Copies of the grandmother’s school certificates and other documents were not accepted as proof of the applicant’s membership; they prove the grandmother’s Croatian origin and identity, but not the applicant’s own earlier and lasting declaration.
The CV, the certificate of no criminal record and other supporting documents were not accepted as proof of membership either, because they show neither personal national affiliation nor the continuous activity in Croatian associations abroad required under Article 16 ZHD.
Descendant of an emigrant (Article 11 ZHD): Why the claimant did not qualify
As regards the provision on descendants of emigrants under Article 11 ZHD, the court found that the emigrant criterion requires the ancestor to have emigrated from the territory of the Republic of Croatia with the intention of residing abroad permanently. Since the file showed that the family emigrated from Croatia to Slovenia and then from Slovenia to Italy, and that the claimant’s mother was born in Slovenia and did not live or work in the Republic of Croatia before moving to Italy, the court concluded that the claimant is not a descendant of an emigrant within the statutory definition. Owing to the lack of evidence of his own earlier declaration of national affiliation and the failure to prove direct emigration from the Republic of Croatia, the court dismissed the claim and upheld the lawfulness of the decision of the Ministry of the Interior.